Peachtree Comfort Heating & Air
Residential HVAC, metro Atlanta · asking $1,200,000 · buyer financing with an SBA 7(a) loan and a 10% seller note
1. My verdict
This is a decent business at the wrong price, and its marketing looks unusually thin for HVAC. Real earnings are about $300K, not the $400K in the listing, and at $1.2M the deal fails the bank's debt test. It also leans harder on the owner and his spouse than the listing lets on.
There may be upside in maintenance plans and the marketing, but it needs data from diligence before you count on it. I'd offer around $850K to $875K, with part of the gap as an earn-out if the seller insists his numbers are right. If he can't support his add-backs or won't move on price, walk.
Published benchmarks next to the seller's numbers. Benchmarks vary by market, so treat them as a guide, not a grade.
| Measure | Typical | This business | My read |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maintenance plans, share of revenue | 15–25% strong, 25%+ top tier | 23% | Healthy. Room to push, not a turnaround |
| Marketing spend, share of revenue | About 6% on average | Under 2% | Far below. Find out where the jobs come from |
| Net profit margin | 5–12% industry average | 3.6% | Below average before add-backs. Ask why |
| Revenue per technician | $150K–$250K a year | Not stated | $2.31M suggests 9 to 15 techs. Ask for the headcount |
Sources: CEO Finance Academy benchmarks via Simpro; ACCA Contractor of the Future study (1,000+ contractors); Simpro HVAC industry statistics 2026.
2. The real earnings
I start from net income on the seller's P&L and test every add-back he claims: is it believable, will it really stop when he leaves, and will you have to replace it? Anything I accept here still needs proof in diligence.
| Add-back | Claimed | I accept | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Owner salary | $120,000 | $120,000 | You'll pay yourself instead |
| Owner health insurance | $18,000 | $18,000 | A normal owner perk; confirm in diligence |
| Owner's truck and fuel | $14,000 | $7,000 | He uses it for install estimates |
| Depreciation and interest | $47,000 | $47,000 | Non-cash, and his debt is paid off at close |
| Lawsuit settlement | $25,000 | $25,000 | Sounds one-time; ask for the agreement |
| Spouse on payroll | $45,000 | $0 | She runs dispatch full time. You'd have to hire |
| "One-time" marketing | $40,000 | $0 | It's in all three years |
| Personal travel | $8,000 | $0 | Left out until he can document it |
| Earnings (SDE), on $83K P&L net income | $400,000 | $300,000 | A 25% haircut |
- Add-backs make up 79% of the earnings he's selling ($317K of $400K). The business itself shows $83K of profit, so almost everything rests on his adjustments.
- Marketing labelled "one-time" appears at the same level in all three years of the P&L.
- Personal travel and the settlement are claimed with no detail. Ask for support before you put a number in your LOI.
3. Will the bank lend?
Lenders want the business to cover its loan payments at least 1.25 times, after paying you a fair salary.
| Seller's numbers | My numbers | |
|---|---|---|
| Earnings (SDE) | $400,000 | $300,000 |
| Less your salary and equipment upkeep | ($115,000) | ($115,000) |
| Annual loan payments at $1.2M | $196,800 | $196,800 |
| Debt coverage | 1.45x · passes | 0.94x · fails |
At these terms, the price that just passes is about $875,000. Assumes 10% down, a 10% seller note at 6% over 5 years, and an SBA loan over 10 years at an illustrative 10.25%.
4. Running it
What changes the day the seller leaves.
5. Possible upside to test
Early signals from the listing, not a growth plan. Each one needs real data in diligence before you count on it or pay for it.
6. The marketing
How customers find the business today, and what to find out before you buy.
7. Questions for the seller
- Can you support the add-backs, especially the $40K of "one-time" marketing, the travel and the settlement?
- How long will you stay to hand over the install estimates, and who could take them on?
- Who replaces your spouse on dispatch, and what would that cost?
- Can the property-management contract be assigned to a new owner? Please send it.
- Where do your leads come from each month, and how many install estimates close?
- Would you carry a larger seller note, or take part of the price as an earn-out?
Once you're under LOI and the seller shares tax returns and bank statements, the Diligence Review checks these numbers against them, tests the upside with real data, goes deeper on staffing and marketing, and helps you structure the deal. Your Deal Check fee is credited.
An operator's review, not an audit, a CPA quality-of-earnings report, or legal, tax or investment advice.
Send me your deal
Tell me a bit about it. I'll reply personally within one business day.